Articles

Read the latest articles relevant to your clinical practice, including exclusive insights from Healthed surveys and polls.

By reading selected clinical articles, you earn CPD in the Educational Activities (EA) category whenever you click the “Claim CPD” button and follow the prompts. 

Dr Trevor W. Beer

Melanoma is rare in childhood, representing no more than 2% of all skin melanomas. Diagnosis is often delayed because melanoma is unsuspected, partly due to differences in presentation and its rarity. The diagnosis is made with trepidation by pathologists, since the vast majority of childhood skin lesions are benign. Establishing the true prevalence of juvenile melanoma is complicated by a number of factors, one being the definition of childhood or juvenile. Many studies use a cut-off age of 19 years, but this is not consistent. Cancer registry data may also be unreliable due to misclassified Spitz naevi, for example.

ABCDE + ABCDD

ABCDE criteria help to identify adult melanoma clinically (Asymmetry, Border irregularity, Colour variation, Diameter >6mm, Evolution). Many melanomas in childhood are non-pigmented (> 50% of 65 recent cases from Victoria). Additional ABCD criteria have been suggested in children: Amelanotic, Bleeding bump, Colour uniformity, De novo, any Diameter to facilitate earlier recognition. Children more often present with advanced disease due to diagnostic delay, reported in 50-60% of patients.

Childhood Melanoma in WA

A recent WA study with the WA Melanoma Advisory Service (WAMAS) identified 95 melanomas in patients 19 years or younger over a 14-year period. Three patients died from melanoma. The majority of tumours, 75%, occurred between ages 13 and 19 years, similar to other studies. In all populations, juvenile melanoma is much less common before puberty. Delayed diagnosis was evident with 21 of 23 patients presenting with Clark level 4 or 5 melanomas with Breslow thickness >1mm in 65%. A family history of melanoma was seen in 17%. A study this year in Victoria revealed 65 melanomas during a 19-year period, with seven fatalities. A decrease in juvenile melanoma has been seen in WA despite an increasing population. In Queensland, a substantial decline occurred between 1997 and 2010, attributed to safer sun exposure practices since the 1980s.

Prognosis

The outlook for childhood melanoma mirrors that in adults being primarily based on stage and Breslow thickness. The exceptions are tumours with spitzoid features. These show appearances resembling Spitz naevi and, although often metastasising to local nodes, are less frequently lethal. Prognostication is complicated by the fact that occasional examples behave aggressively and some spitzoid melanomas in case series may be misdiagnosed Spitz naevi.

Treatment

Complete excision, as in adults, is required. Further investigations and treatment should be decided in conjunction with expert advice. Treatment of advanced melanoma is progressing rapidly and possible eligibility for clinical trials means that patients will get the best opportunities for positive outcomes with personally tailored, up-to-date guidance. It is recommended that all melanoma diagnoses in childhood are reviewed by pathologists with expertise in melanocytic lesions. Referral to a multidisciplinary team is valuable to ensure correct diagnosis and to optimise treatment and advice to patients and families.

Sophie Spitz’s ‘Juvenile Melanoma’

Pathologist Sophie Spitz described 12 unusual ‘juvenile melanomas’ in 1948. Follow-up showed benign behaviour, despite microscopy suggesting melanoma. These lesions are now called Spitz naevi. Although typically childhood lesions, they can occur in adults, reducing in frequency with age. Diagnosis clinically and microscopically can be challenging. Lesions may clinically resemble pyogenic granulomas, haemangioma or dermatofibroma. While most are correctly identified pathologically, some are misdiagnosed as melanoma. Conversely, a leading cause of litigation in pathology is underdiagnosis of melanoma as Spitz naevus. Distinction between Spitz naevi and melanoma may be extremely difficult or even impossible. In these histologically ambiguous tumours inter-observer agreement is notoriously poor. There is now a move away from traditional benign versus malignant divisions with suggestions that a histological continuum exists between Spitz naevi at one end and Spitzoid melanoma at the other. Indeterminate lesions may be labelled Spitzoid tumours of uncertain malignant potential (STUMP) with a guarded prognosis.

Improving pathological diagnostic accuracy

Treatment and prognostication of childhood melanoma requires accurate diagnosis which can be enhanced by experience and consultation between pathologists. Molecular studies such as FISH and aCGH may assist in ambiguous cases, but such methods are still in development and not uniformly available. However, molecular techniques will ultimately lead to more accurate diagnosis, prognostication and tailored treatment for children with melanoma. References available on request
General Practice Pathology is a new regular column each authored by an Australian expert pathologist on a topic of particular relevance and interest to practising GPs. The authors provide this editorial, free of charge as part of an educational initiative developed and coordinated by Sonic Pathology.
Dr Linda Calabresi

Almost three quarters of men with low grade prostate cancer may not be being adequately monitored, a recent Victorian study suggests. According to data from the Prostate Cancer Outcomes Registry – Victoria, only 26.5% of over 1600 men who had low risk prostate cancer had follow-up investigations consistent with standard active surveillance protocols in the two years after their diagnosis. Specifically, researchers were investigating whether these men adhered to the schedule that consisted of at least three PSA measures and at least one biopsy in the two years post diagnosis. While the study authors concede the clinical consequences of this shortcoming are yet unknown, the finding is still of concern. “If [these men] are not being followed appropriately according to [Active Surveillance] protocols, men may miss the opportunity to be treated with curative intent,” they wrote in the MJA. Active surveillance is increasingly the management of choice for men with low risk prostate cancer. In Victoria, 60% of men diagnosed with this grade of cancer are now managed with active surveillance, the study authors said. A major issue with active surveillance as a management option, is that the optimal timing of follow-up investigations has not been strictly defined, resulting in several different protocols and guidelines being developed worldwide.  This, in part was the impetus for the development of the Victorian prostate cancer registry, which was established in 2009 ‘to improve knowledge of patterns of care and outcomes for men diagnosed with prostate cancer.’ Currently the Australian protocol for active surveillance is based on the consensus opinion, and the three PSA tests and repeat biopsy within two years has been widely accepted as standard care. The finding that 73.5% did not receive monitoring in accordance with thisprotocol, reflected adherence levels that were among the worst when compared to similar studies around the world, and the study authors suggested the reason was likely to be multifactorial. The reasons for the non-compliance ‘may reflect patient-, clinician- and health service-related factors,” they wrote. Patients may avoid biopsy because of pain, clinicians may delay testing based on a patient’s comorbidities or health services may have fewer resources for sending reminders or pursuing patients who miss appointments, the study authors suggested. Nonetheless, efforts needed to be made to ensure men with low grade prostate cancer are not disadvantaged in terms of health outcomes if they opt to accept active surveillance as their management strategy. “To improve adherence, a multifaceted approach may be required, including an education campaign that highlights the need for men to undergo regular PSA assessment and prostate biopsy,” they concluded. Ref: MJA doi:10.5694/mja17.00559

Prof Adam Watkins

ON THE PILL: In this seven-part series we explore the history, myths, side-effects and alternatives of the pill, and why it’s the most popular form of contraception in Australia.
The female contraceptive pill has helped millions of women take control of their fertility and reproductive health since it became available in 1961. Yet a male equivalent has yet to be fully developed. This effectively leaves men with only two viable contraceptive options: condoms or a vasectomy. The idea of creating a male contraceptive has been around almost as long as the female contraceptive. In theory, targeting the production of sperm should be a simple process. The biology of sperm production and how they swim towards the egg are well understood. Yet, studies aimed at developing an effective male pill have been dogged by issues such as severe side effects. Most recently, a study that injected men with the hormones testosterone and progestogen – similar to hormones found in the female pill – had to be stopped early.
Read more: Why the male 'pill' is still so hard to swallow
The study, from 2016, showed pregnancy rates for female partners of men receiving the injections fell below that typically seen for women on the pill. But the study was cut short due to reports of adverse side effects including acne, mood disorders and raised libido. For the men taking part, these side effects proved too severe for them to continue, despite the desired drop in sperm production. However, many people may see these side effects as relatively minor compared to those suffered by women on the pill, which include anxiety, weight gain, nausea, headaches, reduced libido and blood clots. Male contraceptives have been under development for at least 50 years. However, the drive to bring a male contraceptive onto the market has stalled for two main reasons. First, there is a general pessimism of men towards taking a contraceptive pill, especially in countries such as India. Second, the global success of the female pill provides little incentive for pharmaceuticals to invest in a male pill. Globally, the female pill is the third most-used form of contraception, with a projected market value of nearly US$23 billion by 2023. Despite these setbacks, a new way of thinking about male contraception is taking shape. Here, the focus has shifted from stopping sperm production to stopping the sperm being able to fertilise the egg.

The clean sheet pill

The clean sheet pill effectively works as its name suggests: preventing the release of sperm. The clean sheet pill has two main selling points. First, by preventing the release of sperm and the fluid they are carried in, the clean sheet pill simultaneously prevents unwanted pregnancy and the spread of sexually-transmitted infections. Second, because the pill does not affect the feeling of orgasm, there is no reduction in male sexual pleasure. Unfortunately, the clean sheet pill has so far only been tested in animals. As such, a version for human use is probably ten years away from being developed.

Vasalgel

One of the downsides of a vasectomy is that it can render a man permanently sterile. However, the recent development of a product call Vasalgel may offer men a serious alternative to a vasectomy. Vasalgel is a long-term, non-hormonal yet reversible form of contraception. This offers benefits over both hormonal contraceptives with their side effects as well as the permanency of a vasectomy. Vasalgel is polymer that is injected into the vas deferens, the tube that carries sperm from the testes. This allows the movement of fluid, but stops the passage of sperm.
Read more: A new male contraceptive could help men bear the family planning burden
In a trial in monkeys, Vasagel was found to be 100% effective at preventing conception. In separate studies in animals, the effect of Vasagel was easily reversed with a simple second injection to dissolve the polymer. If these effects are replicated in men, this could offer a low-cost, minimally invasive and effective contraceptive that is also reversible.

Heart-stopping poisons

A deadly, heart-stopping poison might not sound like a good starting point for a new male contraceptive. However, researchers have shown that a toxic compound call oubain can be be used to slow down the swimming of sperm. Researchers already knew that oubain could affect male fertility. But the cardio toxic effects of oubain prevented scientists from exploring its effects on male reproduction in any detail. By modifying the structure of the oubain molecule, researchers showed it can be used to reduce the motility (ability to swim) of rat sperm while being non-toxic to the heart.

Research and development

While research into male contraceptives have been ongoing for nearly 50 years, we still seem to be at least “five to ten years away” from an effective male pill.
Read more: We won't have a male contraceptive until we change our understanding of risk
Potential new targets for male contraceptives are being developed and tested scientifically all the time. However, without the significant input and push from big pharmaceutical companies, these discoveries may never see the light of day. The ConversationWith the cost of developing a new drug to market estimated at US$2.6 billion, the burden of family planning looks to remain firmly on the shoulders of women for now. Adam Watkins, Assistant Professor, University of Nottingham This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.
Dr Linda Calabresi

In what will be seen as a blow to cryptic crossword compilers the world over, it appears wealth is a better determinant of whether you keep your marbles than education. In a UK prospective study of over 6000 adults aged over 65 years, researchers found those people in the lowest quintile in terms of socioeconomic status were almost 70% more likely to get dementia than those categorised to be in the top fifth, over a 12 year follow-up period. Depressingly, this finding held true regardless of education level. “This longitudinal cohort study found that wealth in late life, but not education, was associated with increased risk of dementia, suggesting people with fewer financial resources were at higher risk,” the study authors said. On further analysis, researchers found the association between wealth, or the lack thereof and dementia was even more pronounced in the younger participants in the cohort. So what did the researchers think was the reason behind the link between poverty and dementia? One explanation was that having money allowed one to access more mentally stimulating environments including cultural resources (reading, theatre etc) and increased social networks that might help preserve cognitive function. While on the flip side, poverty (or ‘persistent socioeconomic disadvantage’ as the authors describe it) affects physiological functioning, increasing the risk of depression, vascular disease and stroke – all known risk factors for dementia. Other factors such as poor diet and lack of exercise also appear to more common among poorer people in the community. All this seems fairly logical, but what of the lack of a protective effect of education? Well, the researchers think this might be a particularly British phenomenon in this age group. “This might be a specific cohort effect in the English population born and educated in the period surrounding the World War II,” they suggested. A number of other studies have shown other results, with some, including the well-respected Canadian Study of Health and Aging-  showing the complete opposite – education protects against dementia. Consequently, the authors of this study, published in JAMA Psychiatry, hypothesise that perhaps this cohort of patients may have been unable to access higher education because of military service or financial restrictions but were able to access intellectually challenging jobs after the war. All in all, the study is an observational one and it is possible there are a number of confounding factors from smoking to availability of medical care that play a role in why poorer people are at greater risk of dementia. And while the researchers are not advocating older people give up their Bridge game and just buy lottery tickets, it would seem money is useful, if not for happiness, then at least for preserving brain power. Ref: JAMA Psychiatry doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2018.1012

Dr Paul Glendenning

Markers of bone turnover, measured in blood or urine, correlate with changes in the metabolic activity of bone. The rate of bone remodelling is important. With ageing, the quantum of bone removed/ resorbed and the amount replaced/ formed becomes increasingly imbalanced. Consequently, the more bone remodelling units that are active at any one time, or the greater the activity of individual units, the greater the overall rate of bone loss. Bone turnover markers are probably predictive of the rate of bone loss and could help determine the efficacy of treatment.

Bone turnover markers:

  • May predict fracture risk independently of bone mineral density, according to some studies.
  • A drop in bone resorption is an early predictor of response to all anti-resorptive osteoporosis treatments initiated in general practice (bisphosphonates, denosumab or raloxifene), with these markers changing earlier than comparable markers of bone formation.
  • They may be predictive of later changes in bone mineral density (BMD), and can be measured before BMD changes can be evaluated.

Which bone resorption marker?

Markers measuring the rate of bone loss are degradation products of type 1 collagen cleaved during bone resorption. Cross-linking telopeptides of collagen can be measured by immunoassays that are specific for the beginning (N terminal- called NTX) or end (C terminal- called CTX) of type 1 collagen. While measuring urinary NTX and serum CTX provide comparable information there are some advantages of CTX over NTX. Consequently, serum CTX has been proposed as a reference method. The measurand in the CTX assay is clearly defined, allowing this 8 amino acid oligopeptide to become the reference method.
  • Most serum CTX is from osteoclastic bone resorption (indicating high specificity).
  • The assay can be performed manually or by automated methods and is only provided by one manufacturer (obviating the need for harmonisation)
  • The biological and analytical variability for CTX is well documented in the literature.

Uses and limitations

Serum CTX is a potentially useful test when investigating the cause of increased alkaline phosphatase, verifying compliance with osteoporosis treatment, improving persistence with that treatment or identifying occult secondary causes of osteoporosis such as apathetic hyperthyroidism or other metabolic bone disorders such as Paget’s disease. Samples collected fasting in the morning minimise intra-individual variation and requests ideally should include the reason for testing. Medicare currently provides a rebate for tests of bone resorption in patients with known bone disease taking treatment.
  1. Not all anti-resorptive treatments suppress bone resorption to the same degree. Provision of the type of anti-resorptive agent used and the duration of treatment is not only helpful for billing but allows us to report more specifically - whether the rate of bone resorption is typical or higher than expected for a particular anti-resorptive agent. For example, denosumab suppresses bone resorption earlier and to a greater degree than a bisphosphonate.
  2. Bone resorption is not predictive of future fracture risk in individuals. CTX can provide complementary information to bone mineral density in subpopulations but this measurement has not been currently adopted into fracture risk alogrithm calculators such as FRAX or the Garvan risk calculator for individuals.
  3. The measurement of serum CTX cannot be used to select treatment. This is because the baseline rate of bone remodelling is not predictive of the rate of change of bone remodelling or rate of change of bone density while on treatment.
  4. Measurement of bone formation and bone resorption do not provide additive information. While bone remodelling is a coupled process wherein bone formation and bone resorption are linked, the measurement of bone resorption or bone formation markers provide comparable information regarding the rate of bone remodelling. Measurements of both bone formation and bone resorption markers in individual patients do not help determine the degree of imbalance in bone remodelling and is therefore unnecessary. Understanding these limitations and the potential value of measuring bone remodelling markers can be useful when making decisions regarding individual patient management in those taking treatment for osteoporosis.
Reproduced with permission from Medical Forum magazine Oct 2017 edition
General Practice Pathology is a new regular column each authored by an Australian expert pathologist on a topic of particular relevance and interest to practising GPs. The authors provide this editorial, free of charge as part of an educational initiative developed and coordinated by Sonic Pathology.
Dr Linda Calabresi

Resistance exercise training significantly reduces depressive symptoms, a new meta-analysis has found. According to international researchers who looked at over 30 randomised clinical trials on the subject, resistance exercise training including activities such as weight lifting reduced depressive symptoms by an average of a third. In fact, the meta-analysis findings suggested that resistance exercise training may be particularly helpful for reducing symptoms in patients with more severe depression. The study results, published in JAMA Psychiatry, concluded that only four people needed to be treated in order to have one to show significant benefit from the intervention. And the improvement inn depressive symptoms occurred regardless of the patient’s overall health status, the volume of resistance training exercise the patient undertook or any improvements in strength the patient experienced. And while the study authors made sure to point out their analysis was not comparing this exercise program with other treatments for depression, reducing symptoms by an average of a third certainly compares with other treatments currently available for this condition. “The available empirical evidence supports [resistance exercise training) as an alternative or adjuvant therapy for depressive symptoms,” the researchers said. What we still don’t know, apparently is exactly what sort of exercise, at what intensity, how frequently and for how long is required until a significant improvement in the depression is achieved. Many of the randomised controlled trials included in the meta-analysis did not measure all these parameters. What the researchers did find was that supervised training programs appeared more effective than non-supervised, which may reflect adherence to the exercise regimen. They also said the most common frequency of resistance exercise training was three times a week. The study authors suggested the limitations of the studies included in this analysis should help direct further research. “Future trials, matching different exercise modes on relevant features of the exercise stimulus, will allow more rigorous and controlled comparisons between exercise modalities, and the examination of interactions between factors such as frequency, intensity, duration and exercise modality,” they said. But regardless of the lack of fine print, the results of this moderate-sized effect of resistance exercise training reported in this study and the complete lack of adverse effects, would seem sufficient to justify recommending it to patients with depression, at least as an adjunctive treatment for one of Australia’s most common mental illnesses. Ref: JAMA Psychiatry doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2018.0572

Dr Kees Van Gool

The winners of this year’s health budget are aged care, rural health and medical research. The government has announced A$1.6 billion over four years to allow 14,000 more older Australians to remain in their home for longer through more high-level home care places. For those in aged care, an additional A$82.5 million will be directed to improve mental health services in the facilities. The budget includes A$83.3 million over five years for a rural health strategy, which aims to place more doctors and nurses in the bush and train 100 additional GPs. There’s A$1.3 billion over ten years for a National Health and Medical Industry Growth Plan, which includes A$500 million for new research in the field of genomics. Other key announcements include: - A$1.4 billion for new and amended listings on PBS - A$302.6 million in savings over forward estimates by encouraging greater use of generic and bio similar medicines - A$253.8 million for a new Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission.
Read more:Infographic: Budget 2018 at a glance

Aged care

Helen Dickinson, Associate Professor, Public Service Research Group at UNSW It was well foreshadowed that this budget would bring with it significant provisions for aged care. It has been widely reported that reforms to pension and superannuation tax have resulted in disaffection in the Coalition within older age groups. Making older Australians the cornerstone of budget measures is a calculated political tactic in a budget that in the short term makes only limited tax cuts for low- and middle-income earners. The A$1.6 billion for 14,000 new places for home-care recipients will be welcome, but are a drop in the ocean, given there are currently more than 100,000 people on the national priority list for support. Additional commitments around trials for physical activities for older people, initiatives to improve connections to communities and protections for older people against abuse will bolster those remaining in homes and communities. Commitments made for specific initiatives for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and aged care facilities in rural and remote Australia will be welcomed, although their size and scope will likely result in little to address older age groups with complex needs. While investment in aged care services will be welcome, it remains to be seen whether this multi-million-dollar commitment will succeed in clawing back support from older voters. Recent years have seen around A$2 billion of cuts made to the sector through adjustments to the residential care funding formula. The current financial commitments go some way to restoring spending, but do not significantly advance spending beyond previous levels in an area of the population we know is expanding substantially in volume and level of need and expectation. A number of new budget commitments have been announced in relation to mental health services for older people in residential aged care facilities, for a national mental health commission, and for Lifeline Australia. However, given the current turbulence in mental health services, it’s unclear whether these will impact on the types of issues that are being felt currently or whether this will further disaggregate an already complex and often unconnected system.

Equity, prevention and Indigenous health

Lesley Russell, Adjunct Associate Professor, Menzies Centre for Health Policy at the University of Sydney The government states its desire for a stronger economy and to limit economic imposts on future generations, but this budget highlights a continued failure to invest in the areas that will deliver more sustainable health care spending, reduce health disparities, and improve health outcomes and productivity for all Australians. We know what the best buys in primary prevention are. But despite the fact that obesity is a heavy and costly burden on the health care system, and the broad agreement from experts on a suite of solutions, this can is once again kicked down the road. There is nothing new to address the harms caused by excessive alcohol use or opioid abuse. The crackdown on illegal tobacco is about lost taxes rather than smoking prevention. There is A$20.9 million over five years to improve the health of women and children – an assorted collection of small programs which could conceivably be claimed as preventive health. There is nothing in this budget to address growing out-of-pocket costs that limit the ability of many to access needed care. Additional funding (given in budget papers as A$83.3 million over five years but more accurately described as A$122.4 million over 2018-19 and 2019-20, with savings of A$55.6 million taken in 2020-21 and 2021-22) is provided for rural health that should help improve health equity for country Australians. Continued funding is provided for the Indigenous Australians’ Health Program (A$3.9 billion over four years); there is new money for ear, eye and scabies programs and also for a new Medicare item for remote dialysis services. There are promises for a new funding model for primary care provided through Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services (but no details) and better access for Indigenous people to aged care. The renewal of the Remote Indigenous Housing Agreement with the Northern Territory will assist with improved health outcomes for those communities.

PBS, medicines and research

Rosalie Viney, Professor of Health Economics at the University of Technology Sydney The budget includes a notable increase in net expenditure on the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS) of A$1.4 billion for new and amended listings of drugs, although most of these have already been anticipated by positive recommendations by the Pharmaceutical Benefits Advisory Committee (PBAC). Access to a number of new medicines has been announced. The new and amended medicine listings are clearly funded through savings in PBS expenditure from greater use of generic and bio-similar medicines, given the net increase in expenditure over the five year outlook is around A$0.7 billion. In terms of medical research, there is an encouraging announcement of significant further investments through the Medical Research Futures Fund. This will be welcomed by health and medical researchers across Australia. What is notable is the focus on the capacity of health and medical research to generate new jobs through new technology. While this is certainly important, it is as much about boosting the local medical technology and innovation industry than on improving health system performance. And the announcements in the budget are as much about the potential job growth from medical innovation as on providing more or improved health services. There is new funding for medical research, development of diagnostic tools and medical technologies, and clinical trials of new drugs. The focus on a 21st century medical industry plan recognises that health is big business as well as being important for all Australians. All of this is welcome, but it will be absolutely critical that there are rigorous processes for evaluating this research and ensuring the funding is allocated based on scientific merit. This can represent a major challenge when industry development objectives are given similar standing in determining priorities as health outcomes and scientific quality.

Rural health

Andrew Wilson, Co-Director, Menzies Centre for Health Policy at the University of Sydney Rural Australians experience a range of health disadvantages including higher rates of smoking and obesity, poorer survival rates from cancer and lower life expectancy, and this is not solely due to the poor health of the Aboriginal community. The government has committed to improving rural health services through the Stronger Rural Health Strategy and the budget has some funding to underpin this. The pressure to fund another medical school in rural NSW and Victoria has been sensibly addressed by enhancing and networking existing rural clinical schools through the Murray Darling Medical Schools network. This will provide more opportunities for all medical students to spend a large proportion of their studentship in a rural setting while not increasing the number of Commonwealth supported places. There is a major need to match this increased student capacity with a greater investment in specialist training positions in regional hospitals to ensure the retention of that workforce in country areas. Hopefully the new workforce incentive program will start to address this.

Hospitals and private health insurance

Peter Sivey, Associate Professor, School of Economics, Finance and Marketing, RMIT University There was no new money in today’s budget for Australia’s beleaguered public hospitals. The government is still locked in a deadlock with Queensland and Victoria, which have refused to agree to the proposed 6.5% cap on yearly funding increases from the Commonwealth. With health inflation of about 4% and population growth close to 2% the cap doesn’t allow much room for increased use due to ageing or new technology. There is no change in the government’s private health insurance policy announced last year and nothing to slow the continuing above-inflation premium rises. The ConversationOn the savings side, there was also no move yet on the private health insurance rebate which some experts think could be scrapped. Kees Van Gool, Health economist, University of Technology Sydney; Andrew Wilson, Co-Director, Menzies Centre for Health Policy, University of Sydney; Helen Dickinson, Associate Professor, Public Service Research Group, UNSW; Lesley Russell, Adjunct Associate Professor, Menzies Centre for Health Policy, University of Sydney; Peter Sivey, Associate Professor, School of Economics, Finance and Marketing, RMIT University, and Rosalie Viney, Professor of Health Economics, University of Technology Sydney This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.
Dr Linda Calabresi

In the last few months of 2017, over 200 Australian infants were hospitalised due to infection with the little known human parechovirus, say Australian public health experts in the latest issue of the MJA. The infected infants were admitted with conditions such as severe sepsis and meningoencephalitis. Less common presentations included acute abdomen from intussusception, pseudo-appendicitis and even bowel perforation. According to the MJA review, parechovirus was originally included under the echovirus umbrella back in the 1960’s, but became an entity in its own right, in the 90’s. There are close to 20 genotypes of the virus, but to date only three (genotypes 1,3 and 6) are thought to cause human disease. For the most part parechovirus causes mild gastro or respiratory tract infections. However, one of the genotypes – genotype 3  - has been found to be considerably more dangerous, especially in babies. “It is now recognised as a leading cause of sepsis-like illness and central nervous system infection, particularly in young infants,” the review authors wrote. The first ‘epidemic’ in Australia of this parechovirus genotype occurred in spring-summer of 2013-2014. Another outbreak occurred two years later – the spring-summer of 2015-2016. This most recent ‘epidemic’ appeared to start in Victoria last August and has now spread nationwide with over 200 infants hospitalised to December. For GPs, the key presenting features to be on the lookout for are fever, irritability and sepsis-like illness – which aren’t very specific. More helpfully - while not all infected children will have a rash, if the presenting infant is ‘red, hot and angry’ -think parechovirus, the authors recommend. Infants younger than three months are most likely to be hospitalised and, of course, really young infants (less than a month old) are at greatest risk of complications so should be sent to hospital earlier rather than later. To diagnose this infection, specific PCR testing needs to be requested of either stool or CSF. Just testing for enteroviruses will not be sufficient. Unfortunately, as yet there is no specific treatment for parechovirus. Given the presentation is the same as that of bacterial sepsis, the review authors suggest antibiotics be commenced until cultures come back negative and bacterial infection is excluded. But other than that, the treatment is mainly supportive and close monitoring and perhaps hospitalisation is required. Of particular concern are a number of studies that suggest infection that is severe enough to require the child be hospitalised is associated with high risk of neurological sequelae. As a consequence, the authors recommend that all children hospitalised with parechovirus be followed up with a paediatrician – at least until they start school- ‘to monitor development and learning, and manage complications including seizures.’ In terms of a vaccine, there is not one yet developed against parechovirus. They suggest research efforts should focus on developing vaccines that target the most pathogenic genotypes of a virus rather than trying to eradicate the entire genus such as has occurred in China with the vaccine against EV71 – a specific enterovirus that causes a complicated hand, foot and mouth disease. Regardless the need to find a vaccine is a priority. “The high morbidity in young children provides a strong case for prevention,” they concluded. Ref: MJA doi: 10.5694/mja18.00149

Dr Smathi Chong

Herpes simplex virus (HSV) 1 and 2 are closely related to each other and more distantly related to Varicella Zoster virus (VZV), which causes Varicella (chicken pox) and Herpes Zoster (shingles). Traditionally HSV1 causes most oral herpes and HSV2 causes most genital herpes. But this is no longer so and has changed, probably due to more frequent oral sex. Figures from Clinipath 2017:
HSV Swab Origin HSV1 HSV2 VZV
Oral sites 93% 2% 5%
Genital/perineal sites 45% 50% 5%
HSV1 is frequently acquired in childhood and 75% of Australian adults would have had HSV1 by early adulthood. This would have been from oral contact with close friends and relatives who were shedding the virus, often asymptomatically. The classic “cold sores” are a blistering painful rash around the mouth Like other viruses in the Herpes family, this ‘lifelong’ infection can lay dormant and reactivate. The risk of reactivation and severe reactivation is higher in immunosuppressed individuals but in most people there is no readily identifiable reason for their reactivation. Stress is often blamed. Less common infections include:
  • HSV encephalitis (HSV1 in adults) and HSV meningitis (usually HSV2 in adults)
  • Conjunctivitis/keratitis – usually HSV1 or VZV (shingles affecting trigeminal nerve)
  • Herpetic whitlow – painful vesicles affecting the finger or thumb caused by HSV1 or 2

Genital Herpes

This causes most angst in patients as there is a social stigma. Approximately one in 7 of the general Australian adult population is seropositive to HSV2 but most are asymptomatic or subclinical. HSV Serology has a more limited role. Many clinicians (and patients) expect Herpes serology to be able to do more than it can! Test results may not answer many clinical or patients’ questions. A positive serology simply indicates a patient has been infected with HSV at some time in the past. It is not able to time the initial infection unless seroconversion (HSV IgG changing from negative to positive) can be demonstrated. In Herpes reactivation, the IgG would already be positive. Serology does not indicate the site of infection (e.g. oral or genital) although a strong positive HSV2 serology in the setting of painful genital lesions is likely to indicate genital herpes. Serology does not confirm whether symptoms are due to herpes. A positive PCR on a genital lesion would be more helpful. Positive serology is not able to tell if the person is infectious at the time of the test. HSV Serology or PCR would NOT be able to determine whether a person’s partner has been unfaithful! False positive (perhaps up to 5%) and false negative serology results can occur. Serology is often negative in acute primary herpes infection as HSV IgG can take a few weeks to a few months to become positive. Serology positivity may also decline over time. HSV IgM is no longer performed in most labs as they often throw up more confusion due to the non-specific nature of the test.

HSV in Pregnancy

HSV can cause severe neonatal infections including meningo-encephalitis, disseminated disease and even death. The highest risk is in symptomatic primary herpes infection of the birth canal/genital track. Herpes simplex serology may be more useful in the setting of pregnancy in patients with genital lesions suggestive of herpes to help risk stratify whether the episode is likely to be primary HSV. The highest risk would be PCR proven active genital lesions and negative serology. Treatment including anti-viral therapy and consideration of caesarean section may be discussed with the obstetrician. Management of the neonate with high risk of HSV should be handled by a neonatologist or paediatrician.

Treatment

These viruses may be treated with aciclovir, valaciclovir or famciclovir.
General Practice Pathology is a new regular column each authored by an Australian expert pathologist on a topic of particular relevance and interest to practising GPs. The authors provide this editorial, free of charge as part of an educational initiative developed and coordinated by Sonic Pathology.
Dr Vivienne Miller

Based on an interview with Dr Jon-Paul Khoo, psychiatrist, co-owner and director at the Toowong Specialist Clinic, Brisbane held at the Annual Women and Children’s Health Update, Melbourne, March 2018 Modern antidepressant medication is efficacious and effective for sufferers of major depressive disorder. However, residual symptoms, even in those who appear to be in remission, are common and can contribute to ongoing distress. Sexual dysfunction is one particularly relevant example. Up to a quarter of the general population report this, and the rate increases to about half of those who are depressed but not on treatment. Sexual dysfunction may affect up to 80% of treated depressed people and is affected by their background, the depression itself and the treatment. Even when mood recovery occurs, sexual dysfunction can persist. As GPs are the main prescribers of antidepressants in Australia, before choosing a medication, they need to feel informed and comfortable when discussing the impact of depression and its treatment on all aspects of functioning, specifically sexual functioning. Following a complete assessment, the GP may feel that antidepressant medication is indicated. This would be an opportune time to ask about current sexual function. It is likely to be a more comfortable discussion if the patient and doctor are already acquainted, but even if this is not the case, it a straight-forward approach with some advance warning about the need for personal questions often helps. “We have to introduce the topic of sexual dysfunction as very few patients will spontaneously bring up this topic”, says psychiatrist Dr Jon-Paul Khoo. Sexual behaviour in humans is complex, individual and highly personal. Nothing should be assumed about the patient’s sexual habits. It may be necessary to discuss relationship problems, at-risk behaviour, sociocultural issues and medical conditions affecting sexual function. It should also be discussed with patients that many people in the general population who are not depressed have sexual dysfunction. Given this, the usual sexual dysfunction associated with antidepressant use in women is lack of desire and difficulty achieving orgasm. The usual sexual dysfunction associated with antidepressant use in men is lack of desire, erectile dysfunction and delayed or absent ejaculation. The impact of these side-effects may be more severe for men than for women (although sexual side-effects occur more commonly in women). People who have less supportive relationships, those in the older age groups, those with medical conditions and those with sexual problems prior to the depression, or because of it, are most likely to be adversely affected sexually by antidepressant medication. On the positive side, antidepressants may be beneficial in patients who have premature ejaculation. Furthermore, judicious decision-making about antidepressant type may allow those with pre-existing impotence, pain disorders and sexual dysfunction due to other causes to undertake effective treatment without a worsening of sexual dysfunction We are familiar with efficacy data and the overall clinical utility of antidepressant medications, but we are less well-educated regarding the adverse sexual effects of treatment. Although there are minimal efficacy differences between antidepressant therapies in the treatment of major depressive disorder, there are distinct tolerability differences. The propensity for causing sexual dysfunction varies both between and within antidepressant subtypes. A brief summary of antidepressant-induced sexual dysfunction is that approximately 80% of people taking (most types of) selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRI) or venlafaxine, a serotonin noradrenaline reuptake inhibitor (SNRI), will report some sort of adverse sexual effect. A more moderate risk of sexual dysfunction occurs with imipramine, as well as escitalopram and fluvoxamine (both SSRIs) and duloxetine (an SNRI). The lowest rates of sexual dysfunction (placebo-equivalent rates) in controlled studies are reported with agomelatine, moclobemide, mirtazapine (though sedation may affect desire) and vortioxitine (on pooled analysis). In comparison, atypical antipsychotics have a higher rates of sexual dysfunction than antidepressant therapies, probably related to their propensity to elevate prolactin. It is wise to exclude or manage drug and alcohol issues, and to discuss with the patient the adverse effect of these regarding both the remission of depression and adequate sexual functioning. Patients at high risk of, or who already have, pre-existing sexual dysfunction should be commenced on a low-risk antidepressant when clinically reasonable. If a higher risk medication is working well for mood stability, the patient may decide not to change treatments. Commonly cited strategies of waiting for sexual dysfunction to improve with time, or scheduling sexual activity against dosing, have limited benefit for the majority of patients. Similarly, dose reduction and ‘drug holidays’ are not generally effective. The most gain in arresting sexual dysfunction occurs with changing the antidepressant to a lower risk alternative. Augmenting the antidepressant therapy with an intervention that might improve any induced sexual dysfunction is probably the next best option. For women, this might include exercise 30 minutes prior to sexual activity, as may increasing the frequency of sexual activity. For men, the best augmentation strategy appears to be prostaglandin E inhibitors. There are data for both sildenafil and tadalafil, both of which are indicated in men who have sexual dysfunction. Finally, it is also suggested that involving the partner, where appropriate, may help reduce stigma and increase support and understanding for patients affected by sexual dysfunction.

Dr Anup Desai

Insomnia is a common condition in which patients experience difficulty initiating sleep, maintaining sleep and/or wake earlier than desired. It can cause significant distress and impaired functioning. Population surveys suggest that approximately 33% of the population experience at least one insomnia symptom, with only 1 in 10 seeking treatment. Female gender, older age, pain and psychological distress have all been associated with increased prevalence rates. There is a strong association between insomnia and psychiatric disorders, such as depression, anxiety, and drug abuse. Rates of psychiatric comorbidity as high as 80% have been reported, with insomnia predating the onset of mood disorder in approximately half of cases. Insomnia has also been independently associated with increased healthcare utilisation, increased workplace injuries and absenteeism, and reductions in quality of life. A number of studies have demonstrated an association between insomnia and increased cardiovascular risk. The management of insomnia can broadly be categorised into pharmacological and non -pharmacological therapies. Although pharmacotherapy is often used first by doctors and as primary therapy, it is not indicated long term and should not be used in isolation. Pharmacotherapy is only indicated for short term use. Benzodiazepines, non-benzodiazepine hypnotics, melatonin, sedating anti-depressants and antipsychotics have all been used. The majority of these agents have been shown to be more efficacious than placebo in short term randomised controlled trials, however their use is often tempered by extensive side effect profiles, detrimental effects on sleep architecture and the risk of tolerance and dependence. Non-drug treatments for insomnia, namely Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) for sleep are very effective both acutely and for the longer term. CBT for sleep should be initiated in all patients. CBT is effective as a sole treatment for insomnia or it may reduce the reliance on medications in the longer term. CBT addresses dysfunctional behaviours and beliefs about sleep and consists of sleep hygiene, stimulus control, sleep restriction, and cognitive restructuring. In the past, access to CBT for sleep has been a challenge, with limited trained providers and poor availability. However, recent studies of computer based (online) CBT for sleep have been encouraging with comparable efficacy to conventional CBT for sleep. Online CBT can be accessed in Australia through the US based SHUTi program if referred by GP’s or Specialists (http://www.sleepcentres.com.au/online-insomnia-cbt-program.html). Online CBT for sleep is convenient, effective and easy to access, and arguably is a good option for non-drug insomnia management for all patients.

Dr Vivienne Miller

Based on an interview with endocrinologist and obesity expert, Professor Joseph Proietto at the Annual Women and Children’s Health Update, Melbourne, March 2018 There are many reasons proposed for our society becoming more overweight than ever before. The commonest explanation is that people are overeating because they have more refined, energy dense foods easily available and requiring little physical effort to access. The other consideration is that people are not moving and exercising as much, due to increased sedentary employment and entertainments that are clearly less effort. Once people become overweight, they feel less like exercising and so the situation worsens. Unfortunately, in our society, food (including alcohol), socialising and entertainment are all strongly associated. Food is easily obtained and is abundant in variety and quantity. Previous generations ate less because of cost, availability and the fact that food generally plainer and perhaps less tasty. This was especially true for the poorer in society, who also tended to have more physically demanding jobs, with less time and money to spend on eating during the day. On a scientific level, genetics and epigenetics are now known to play an important role in the development of obesity. In particular, there are many genes currently being researched in relation to appetite and obesity including leptin (a hormone made mostly by adipose cells that inhibits hunger) and its receptor, and the melanocortin 4 receptor. "For obvious evolutionary reasons, there are no genes (yet) identified that reduce metabolic rate," said Professor Joseph Proietto. So far, all genes that have been found to be associated with obesity have been linked to increased hunger. There are no genes known that reduce metabolism. It is interesting that force-feeding increases energy expenditure while weight loss reduces energy expenditure and, in both cases, it is spontaneous activity that changes, with only minor alteration in basal metabolic rate. This has been demonstrated in overfeeding experiments. Some causes of obesity may be epigenetic. For example, some women who gain excess weight during pregnancy find it more difficult to lose after the pregnancy. This is likely to be due to epigenetic change in the expression of genes connected with obesity. Unfortunately, the offspring of mothers who become overweight before or during pregnancy are likely to inherit these genes, and hence themselves have trouble with weight gain. Certain medical conditions (hypothyroidism, Cushing's syndrome) may induce modest weight gain, but the extreme numbers of people in our society with serious weight problems mean that endocrinological causes are very much in the minority. Hence, we need to look for other causes for obesity in the modern age. One of the biggest problems with healthy lifestyle programmes and extensive community information about diet, weight and exercise in our society is that genetics trump willpower in many cases, especially over the long-term. Following weight loss there are hormonal changes that lead to increased hunger (leptin levels fall and ghrelin levels increase) and in 2011 these changes were shown to be long lasting, so the weight-reduced individual has to fight increased hunger. Given the prolific amount of available food, temptation adds to the problem. In effect, one is then fighting nature.